Marcellus Lanes (Ice Cream) Information

Stepping into Marcellus Lanes (Ice Cream) on Slate Hill Rd instantly feels like slipping into a warm slice of small-town charm. The first thing that hits you is the welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere that makes it clear this isn’t just a spot for a quick dessert-it’s a place where locals and visitors alike linger, laughing over cones and sundaes. The menu here leans heavily on classic ice cream favorites, from creamy scoops in traditional flavors like vanilla bean and rich chocolate to more playful seasonal specials that rotate regularly, keeping things fresh and exciting. For anyone with a sweet tooth, the sundae options are a standout, with generous toppings, drizzles, and whipped cream piled high, perfect for sharing-or not.

What really makes this location shine is the balance between quality and variety. The ice cream is consistently smooth and flavorful, made with care and attention to texture that you can taste in every bite. Waffle cones are crisp without being overly sweet, and the toppings bar adds a fun interactive touch, letting guests personalize their treats exactly how they like. Reviews often highlight the friendly, approachable staff, who seem genuinely invested in making sure every customer leaves with a smile and a perfectly crafted dessert. Service is brisk, even on busier afternoons, yet never feels rushed, which adds to the relaxed, welcoming vibe.

The space itself has a cozy, slightly nostalgic feel, with colorful accents and seating that invites conversation. While the main draw is clearly the ice cream, Marcellus Lanes also has an adjacent bowling area, making it a unique blend of entertainment and indulgence-perfect for families, date nights, or casual meetups with friends. Patrons frequently mention how easy it is to park and the convenient location off the main road, making it a natural stop whether you’re on a weekend outing or just passing through Marcellus. Overall, the combination of delectable frozen treats, attentive service, and a genuinely fun environment makes Marcellus Lanes (Ice Cream) a spot that keeps people coming back, scoop after scoop.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

Do you want a lot of ice cream? Order a kiddie size... And if you want way too much ice cream that no human can consume, get anything bigger. Tempt fate if you dare. Prices are phenomenal for the amount you get and the ice cream tastes like ice cream. I highly recommend bringing 3 friends and sharing a small, but you do you. The staff was very kind and the service was fast. Enjoy!!

If you like ice cream, I’m pretty sure you’ll love this place. Flavor and format permutations seem endless and the staff don’t flinch at unique requests or customizations. I would personally recommend the vanilla soft serve, dipped in PB, fudge chocolate drizzle, and topped with whipped cream. BYO Lactaid pill.

This is hands-down the best place in NY to get ice cream. Best pricing and bang for your buck!! I’ve attached pictures of smalls. Tons of options. However, the last time I went I will have to agree with some of these previous reviews - I’ve never encountered the older woman who works there until then - she is rude and miserable. I usually get my sprinkles on the side (as seen in one picture) because the chocolate dip turns them to stone and I like to dip the ice cream into them. It has never been an issue/been questioned until this last time when she was there. “You either get it on it or you don’t, I don’t put it on the sides” were her words. She then did a meager dip into the chocolate and threw a small amount of sprinkles on my ice cream. The younger workers are better, by far! So maybe just avoid her.

Love coming here in the summer for the ice cream Huge servings and priced very reasonable Bowling part is ok Building for sure needs an update But over all a good place to bowl a couple games

Hands down the best soft serve ice cream around. Service is fast and portion size is high! The price is affordable. A kiddy cone is the size of a regular medium, a large cone is HUGH! Kids love this place and it offered a variety of options. Service is fast and efficient, mostly college students and they are great workers!

We had heard the ice creams were huge...that was an understatement! What really made the experience was that the staff was very nice and the ice cream was yummy. So glad we read someone else's review and took the drive to this great place!

The Ice Cream here is amazing! They are huge! So much bigger than any other shop. They are affordable, not over priced at all! I love coming here! You will leave with a smile for sure. Service is great too. They're soooo sweet and friendly! The ice cream is definitely something to talk about! Go try it, and you'll see what I mean!!

My family and I are obsessed with the ice cream here! They give you way more than you pay for and the taste is better than anywhere else around. :)

Marcellus Lanes (Ice Cream)